Card # | Player | Team | Type | Rookie | Insert Name |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1A | Base Dead TED | Dead TED Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 2A | Base Nasty NICK | Dead TED Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 3A | Base ADAM Bomb | Dead TED Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 4A | Base Weird WENDY | Dead TED Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 5A | Base Cranky FRANKIE | Dead TED Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 6A | Base Bony JOANIE | Dead TED Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 7A | Base New Wave DAVE | Dead TED Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 8A | Base Greaser GREG | Dead TED Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 9A | Base Wrappin' RUTH | Dead TED Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 10A | Base Slimy SAM | SY Clops Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 11A | Base Junk Food JOHN | SY Clops Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 12A | Base Stormy HEATHER | SY Clops Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 13A | Base SCOTTIE Potty | SY Clops Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 14A | Base SY Clops | SY Clops Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 15A | Base Leaky LINDSAY | SY Clops Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 16A | Base Shrunken ED | SY Clops Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 17A | Base Fryin' RYAN | SY Clops Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 18A | Base Tee Vee STEVIE | SY Clops Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 19A | Base Hot SCOTT | Ghastly ASHLEY Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 20A | Base Brainy Janie | Ghastly ASHLEY Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 21A | Base Mad MAX | Ghastly ASHLEY Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 22A | Base Jolly ROGER | Ghastly ASHLEY Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 23A | Base Ghastly ASHLEY | Ghastly ASHLEY Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 24A | Base Tatoo LOU | Ghastly ASHLEY Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 25A | Base PATTY Putty | Ghastly ASHLEY Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 1B | Base Jay Decay | Ghastly ASHLEY Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 2B | Base Evil EDDIE | Ghastly ASHLEY Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 3B | Base Blasted BILLY | Blasted BILLY Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 4B | Base Haggy MAGGIE | Blasted BILLY Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 5B | Base Bad BRAD | Blasted BILLY Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 6B | Base Thin LYNN | Blasted BILLY Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 7B | Base Graffiti PETEY | Blasted BILLY Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 8B | Base CHRIS Hiss | Blasted BILLY Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 9B | Base TOMMY Tomb | Blasted BILLY Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 10B | Base Lizard LIZ | Blasted BILLY Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 11B | Base RAY Decay | Blasted BILLY Puzzle | Base | Base Cards | |
| 12B | Base APRIL Showers | JASON Basin PUZZLE | Base | Base Cards | |
| 13B | Base JASON Basin | JASON Basin PUZZLE | Base | Base Cards | |
| 14B | Base One-Eyed JACK | JASON Basin PUZZLE | Base | Base Cards | |
| 15B | Base Messy TESSIE | JASON Basin PUZZLE | Base | Base Cards | |
| 16B | Base Cheeky CHARLES | JASON Basin PUZZLE | Base | Base Cards | |
| 17B | Base Charred CHAD | JASON Basin PUZZLE | Base | Base Cards | |
| 18B | Base Geeky GARY | JASON Basin PUZZLE | Base | Base Cards | |
| 19B | Base LUKE Warm | JASON Basin PUZZLE | Base | Base Cards | |
| 20B | Base JENNY Genius | JASON Basin PUZZLE | Base | Base Cards | |
| 21B | Base Brainy BRIAN | Completed Puzzle 1 | Base | Base Cards | |
| 22B | Base Pegleg PETER | Completed Puzzle 2 | Base | Base Cards | |
| 23B | Base Acne AMY | Completed Puzzle 3 | Base | Base Cards | |
| 24B | Base ART Gallery | Completed Puzzle 4 | Base | Base Cards | |
| 25B | Base Muggin' MEGAN | Completed Puzzle 5 | Base | Base Cards | |
| 1C | Insert Bucket Head JED | C Name Back | Base | C Names | |
| 2C | Insert Defanged DEVON | C Name Back | Base | C Names | |
| 3C | Insert Smashed ASH | C Name Back | Base | C Names | |
| 4C | Insert Broom HILDA | C Name Back | Base | C Names | |
| 5C | Insert Gluttonous GARY | C Name Back | Base | C Names | |
| 6C | Insert Missed MISTY | C Name Back | Base | C Names | |
| 7C | Insert Street ART | C Name Back | Base | C Names | |
| 8C | Insert BUZZ Cut | C Name Back | Base | C Names | |
| 9C | Insert Mischievous MITCH | C Name Back | Base | C Names | |
| 10C | Insert Reptile KYLE | C Name Back | Base | C Names | |
| 11C | Insert Razor RAYMOND | C Name Back | Base | C Names | |
| 12C | Insert HEIDI Voltage | C Name Back | Base | C Names | |
| 13C | Insert Bobbin' ROBIN | C Name Back | Base | C Names | |
| 14C | Insert MANNY Eyeballs | C Name Back | Base | C Names | |
| 15C | Insert Drac Drip PIP | C Name Back | Base | C Names | |
| 16C | Insert Bite-Size RANDY | C Name Back | Base | C Names | |
| 17C | Insert Door to DORA | C Name Back | Base | C Names | |
| 18C | Insert TELLY Vision | C Name Back | Base | C Names | |
| 19C | Insert PATTY Melt | C Name Back | Base | C Names | |
| 20C | Insert Snacky JACKIE | C Name Back | Base | C Names | |
| 21C | Insert Candy Head NED | C Name Back | Base | C Names | |
| 22C | Insert BILLY Bones | C Name Back | Base | C Names | |
| 23C | Insert Tricky TRISH | C Name Back | Base | C Names | |
| 24C | Insert Flashy FLETCHER | C Name Back | Base | C Names | |
| 25C | Insert Cauldron COLLEEN | C Name Back | Base | C Names | |
| 1A | Insert JAMIE LEE Hurtus | Scream Queens #1 | Base | Scream Queens | |
| 1B | Insert Lurking LAURIE | Base | Scream Queens | ||
| 2A | Insert JANET Leeks | Scream Queens #2 | Base | Scream Queens | |
| 2B | Insert Crazed CRANE | Base | Scream Queens | ||
| 3A | Insert Nervous NEVE | Scream Queens #3 | Base | Scream Queens | |
| 3B | Insert Snotty SIDNEY | Base | Scream Queens | ||
| 4A | Insert MICHELLE Yeller | Scream Queens #4 | Base | Scream Queens | |
| 4B | Insert Hairless HELEN | Base | Scream Queens | ||
| 5A | Insert HEATHER Langentrapped | Scream Queens #5 | Base | Scream Queens | |
| 5B | Insert Nightmre NANCY / Variation Bony Joanie / Variation Ghastly ASHLEY / Variation Adam Bomb / Variation PATTY Putty / Variation Mad Max / Variation Tee Vee Stevie / Variation New Wave Dave / Variation Jolly Rogers / Variation Scottie Potty / Variation Brainy JANIE / Autos Dead Ted / 1 / Autos Mad Max / 2 / Autos Adam Bomb / 3 / Autos Stormy HEATHER / 4 / Autos Shrunken ED / 5 / Autos Tatoo LOU / 6 / Autos New Wave Dave / 7 / Autos Sy Clops / 8 / Autos Nasty Nick / 9 / Autos Bony Joanie / 10 / Matthew Skillern / Michael Mastermaker / Nik Muggli / Taylor Allen “Uncle / John Monserrat / Matthew Maldonado / Mike Ritchey / Lowell Isaac Hildebrandt / Niel Camera / Brandhen / Daniel Goodroad / Isiah Xavier Bradley / Jason Bryant / JBoom / Joey Fitchett / Keith Farnum / Kimber Grobman / Lily Z Mercado / Lisa Hall / Paul D / Richard Rios / RJ Tomascik / Robert Blancas / Sandy Meeks / Sobot Cortez / Steve Crockett / Ted Dastick Jr. / Tim Shinn / Tom Amaci / Victor Moreno / Adam Edwards / Adam Harris / Anthony Pietszak / Eric Lehtonen / Jose David Acevedo / Brandon Layng / Christopher Meeks / Darrin Pepe / Edward Loren Rhodes / Guy K. Holzer / Bryan A. Siegel / Carmen Santaferrara / Chad Scheres / Dustin Graham / Eric Medina / Erik Shane Muller / Maurice J. Gilligan / Nikolas Castaneda / Patrick Giles / Robert Blakey / Simone Arena / Stanley Stylianou / Vincenzo D'ippolito | Joe Simko / Neil Camera / David Gross / Smokin Joe / Brent Engstrom / Wax” / “Ziggy” / Jr. / (Rusty) | Base | Scream Queens |