2023 Topps Five Star Baseball keeps the autograph-first format intact while adding Quintuple Relic Autographs and deeper five-player book cards to the premium hit mix. The autograph side remains broad with Base Autographs, Silver Signatures, Golden Graphs, Baseball Royalty, Five Star Signatures, Five Tool Phenom Autographs, and Pentamerous Penmanship, and the stronger rookie group helps make this one of the more modern-focused Five Star checklists. This checklist file tracks 507 total cards, including 455 autographs, 52 autograph relics, and 89 rookies.
Card # | Player | Team | Type | Rookie | Insert Name |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FSJP-AB | Adrian Beltre | Texas Rangers | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-AJ | Aaron Judge | New York Yankees | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-ARI | Austin Riley | Atlanta Braves | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-ARIZ | Anthony Rizzo | New York Yankees | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-ARU | Adley Rutschman | Baltimore Orioles | autorelic | ✓ | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS |
| FSJP-BB | Byron Buxton | Minnesota Twins | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-BH | Bryce Harper | Philadelphia Phillies | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-BW | Bobby Witt Jr. | Kansas City Royals | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-Bba Brett Baty | New York Mets | autorelic | ✓ | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-CC | Corbin Carroll | Arizona Diamondbacks | autorelic | ✓ | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS |
| FSJP-CY | Christian Yelich | Milwaukee Brewers | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-DJ | Derek Jeter | New York Yankees | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-FÁ Francisco Alvarez | New York Mets | autorelic | ✓ | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-GH | Gunnar Henderson | Baltimore Orioles | autorelic | ✓ | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS |
| FSJP-JJ | Josh Jung | Texas Rangers | autorelic | ✓ | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS |
| FSJP-JS | Juan Soto | San Diego Padres | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-JV | Joey Votto | Cincinnati Reds | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-MC | Matt Chapman | Toronto Blue Jays | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-MH | Michael Harris II | Atlanta Braves | autorelic | ✓ | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS |
| FSJP-MMA | Manny Machado | San Diego Padres | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-MS | Mike Schmidt | Philadelphia Phillies | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-NG | Nolan Gorman | St. Louis Cardinals | autorelic | ✓ | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS |
| FSJP-OP | Oswald Peraza | New York Yankees | autorelic | ✓ | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS |
| FSJP-PG | Paul Goldschmidt | St. Louis Cardinals | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-RA | Ronald Acuña Jr. | Atlanta Braves | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-RD | Rafael Devers | Boston Red Sox | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-RG | Riley Greene | Detroit Tigers | autorelic | ✓ | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS |
| FSJP-RH | Rhys Hoskins | Philadelphia Phillies | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-SA | Sandy Alcantara | Miami Marlins | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-SO | Shohei Ohtani | Angels | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-SR | Scott Rolen | Cincinnati Reds | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-TH | Torii Hunter | Angels | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-VG | Vladimir Guerrero Jr. | Toronto Blue Jays | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSQRA-AJ | Aaron Judge | New York Yankees | autorelic | FIVE STAR Quintuple RELIC Autographs | |
| FSQRA-BW | Bobby Witt Jr. | Kansas City Royals | autorelic | FIVE STAR Quintuple RELIC Autographs | |
| FSQRA-DJ | Derek Jeter | New York Yankees | autorelic | FIVE STAR Quintuple RELIC Autographs | |
| FSQRA-I | Ichiro | Seattle Mariners | autorelic | FIVE STAR Quintuple RELIC Autographs | |
| FSQRA-JR | Julio Rodríguez | Seattle Mariners | autorelic | FIVE STAR Quintuple RELIC Autographs | |
| FSQRA-JS | Juan Soto | San Diego Padres | autorelic | FIVE STAR Quintuple RELIC Autographs | |
| FSQRA-MC | Miguel Cabrera | Detroit Tigers | autorelic | FIVE STAR Quintuple RELIC Autographs | |
| FSQRA-MT | Mike Trout | Angels | autorelic | FIVE STAR Quintuple RELIC Autographs | |
| FSQRA-PA | Pete Alonso | New York Mets | autorelic | FIVE STAR Quintuple RELIC Autographs | |
| FSQRA-PG | Paul Goldschmidt | St. Louis Cardinals | autorelic | FIVE STAR Quintuple RELIC Autographs | |
| FSQRA-RA | Ronald Acuña Jr. | Atlanta Braves | autorelic | FIVE STAR Quintuple RELIC Autographs | |
| FSQRA-SO | Shohei Ohtani | Angels | autorelic | FIVE STAR Quintuple RELIC Autographs | |
| FSQRA-VG | Vladimir Guerrero Jr. | Toronto Blue Jays | autorelic | FIVE STAR Quintuple RELIC Autographs | |
| FSBC-AMPSG | Paul Goldschmidt / Ozzie Smith / Albert Pujols / Nolan Arenado / Mark McGwire | St. Louis Cardinals | autorelic | FIVE STARS Autograph RELIC BOOK CARDS | |
| FSBC-HAGFR | Paul Goldschmidt / Pete Alonso / Anthony Rizzo / Rhys Hoskins / Freddie Freeman | St. Louis Cardinals / New York Mets / New York Yankees / Philadelphia Phillies / Los Angeles Dodgers | autorelic | FIVE STARS Autograph RELIC BOOK CARDS | |
| FSBC-JMDSS | Sammy Sosa / Andre Dawson / Greg Maddux / Fergie Jenkins / Ryne Sandberg | Chicago Cubs | autorelic | FIVE STARS Autograph RELIC BOOK CARDS | |
| FSBC-KHMRI | Ichiro / Felix Hernández / Edgar Martinez / Julio Rodríguez / George Kirby | Seattle Mariners | autorelic | FIVE STARS Autograph RELIC BOOK CARDS | |
| FSBC-MFDYO | Pedro Martinez / Carlton Fisk / Rafael Devers / Carl Yastrzemski / David Ortiz | Boston Red Sox | autorelic | FIVE STARS Autograph RELIC BOOK CARDS | |
| FSBC-PHRCW | Oneil Cruz / Julio Rodríguez / Bobby Witt Jr. / Michael Harris II / Jeremy Peña | Pittsburgh Pirates / Seattle Mariners / Kansas City Royals / Atlanta Braves / Houston Astros | autorelic | FIVE STARS Autograph RELIC BOOK CARDS | |
| FSA-ABE | Adrian Beltre | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-ADA | Andre Dawson | Montreal Expos | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-AMA | Alek Manoah | Toronto Blue Jays | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-ARIL | Austin Riley | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-ARIZZ | Anthony Rizzo | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-ARO | Alex Rodriguez | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-ARUS | Adley Rutschman | Baltimore Orioles | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-AT | Alek Thomas | Arizona Diamondbacks | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-AV | Anthony Volpe | New York Yankees | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-BB1 | Brett Baty | New York Mets | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-BBE1 | Brayan Bello | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-BBU | Byron Buxton | Minnesota Twins | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-BEN | Johnny Bench | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-BJN | Bo Jackson | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-BL | Barry Larkin | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-BOJ | Bo Jackson | Kansas City Royals | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-BWI1 | Bobby Witt Jr. | Kansas City Royals | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-BWI2 | Bobby Witt Jr. | Kansas City Royals | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-CA | CJ Abrams | Washington Nationals | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-CCAR | Corbin Carroll | Arizona Diamondbacks | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-CFI | Carlton Fisk | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-CHI | Chipper Jones | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-CM | Christopher Morel | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-CRA | Cole Ragans | Texas Rangers | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-CRJ | Cal Ripken Jr. | Baltimore Orioles | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-CYE | Christian Yelich | Milwaukee Brewers | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-DW | Drew Waters | Kansas City Royals | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-DWI | Dave Winfield | Minnesota Twins | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-EMU | Eddie Murray | Los Angeles Dodgers | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-EMU | Eddie Murray | Baltimore Orioles | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-EP | Eury Pérez | Miami Marlins | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-FA | Francisco Alvarez | New York Mets | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-FTJ | Fernando Tatis Jr. | San Diego Padres | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-GHE | Gunnar Henderson | Baltimore Orioles | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-GKI | George Kirby | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-GMI1 | Garrett Mitchell | Milwaukee Brewers | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-GMOR | Gabriel Moreno | Arizona Diamondbacks | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-GR | Grayson Rodriguez | Baltimore Orioles | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-GSP | George Springer | Toronto Blue Jays | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-HIM | Hideki Matsui | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-HW | Hayden Wesneski | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-ICH | Ichiro | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-IHE | Iván Herrera | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-JA | Javier Assad | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-JBL1 | JJ Bleday | Oakland Athletics | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-JBL2 | JJ Bleday | Oakland Athletics | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-JCH | Jazz Chisholm Jr. | Miami Marlins | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-JD | Jeter Downs | Washington Nationals | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-JG | Jordan Groshans | Miami Marlins | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-JJU | Josh Jung | Texas Rangers | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-JME | Joey Meneses | Washington Nationals | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-JPE | Jeremy Peña | Houston Astros | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-JR | Jimmy Rollins | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-JROD | Julio Rodríguez | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-JSOT | Juan Soto | San Diego Padres | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-JV | Joey Votto | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-JW | Jordan Walker | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-KS | Kyle Stowers | Baltimore Orioles | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-LO | Logan O'Hoppe | Angels | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-LOH | Logan O'Hoppe | Angels | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-LP | Liover Peguero | Pittsburgh Pirates | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-LPE | Liover Peguero | Pittsburgh Pirates | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-LRO | Luis Robert | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-LRO | Luis Robert | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-MCG | Mark McGwire | Oakland Athletics | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-MFR | Max Fried | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-MGO | MacKenzie Gore | Washington Nationals | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-MHA | Michael Harris II | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-ML | Matthew Liberatore | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-MM | Max Meyer | Miami Marlins | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-MMAC | Manny Machado | San Diego Padres | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-MMC | Mark McGwire | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-MRI | Mariano Rivera | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-MTO | Michael Toglia | Colorado Rockies | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-MTR | Mike Trout | Angels | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-MV | Mark Vientos | New York Mets | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-MY | Masataka Yoshida | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-NGOR | Nolan Gorman | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-NJ | Nolan Jones | Colorado Rockies | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-NPR | Nick Pratto | Kansas City Royals | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-NRY | Nolan Ryan | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-OCE | Orlando Cepeda | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-OP | Oswald Peraza | New York Yankees | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-ORT | David Ortiz | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-PED | Pedro Martinez | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-PGO | Paul Goldschmidt | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-PIA | Mike Piazza | New York Mets | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-PM | Paul Molitor | Milwaukee Brewers | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-RAN | Randy Johnson | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-RDE | Reid Detmers | Angels | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-RG | Riley Greene | Detroit Tigers | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-RYO | Robin Yount | Milwaukee Brewers | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-SAL1 | Sandy Alcantara | Miami Marlins | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-SAL2 | Sandy Alcantara | Miami Marlins | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-SCA | Steve Carlton | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-SEA | Corey Seager | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-SL | Shea Langeliers | Oakland Athletics | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-SMO | John Smoltz | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-SST | Spencer Strider | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-TC | Triston Casas | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-TF | Tyler Freeman | Cleveland Guardians | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-TG | Tom Glavine | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-TH | Tommy Henry | Arizona Diamondbacks | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-THO | Frank Thomas | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-VGRI | Vaughn Grissom | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-VLA | Vladimir Guerrero Jr. | Toronto Blue Jays | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-VOT | Joey Votto | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-WBE1 | Will Benson | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-WBE2 | Will Benson | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-WBO | Wade Boggs | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-WBUE | Walker Buehler | Los Angeles Dodgers | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-WC | Will Clark | San Francisco Giants | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| SS-AD | Andre Dawson | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-AM | Alek Manoah | Toronto Blue Jays | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-AR | Anthony Rizzo | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-ARI | Austin Riley | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-BB | Brett Baty | New York Mets | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures |
| SS-BW | Bobby Witt Jr. | Kansas City Royals | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-CA | CJ Abrams | Washington Nationals | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-DM | Don Mattingly | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-FÁ Francisco Alvarez | New York Mets | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-GM | Gabriel Moreno | Arizona Diamondbacks | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures |
| SS-GS | Gary Sheffield | Milwaukee Brewers | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-JC | Jose Canseco | Oakland Athletics | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-JCH | Jazz Chisholm Jr. | Miami Marlins | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-JM | Juan Marichal | San Francisco Giants | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-JP | Jorge Posada | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-JR | José Ramírez | Cleveland Guardians | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-JRO | Julio Rodríguez | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-JS | John Smoltz | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-MC | Matt Chapman | Toronto Blue Jays | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-MF | Max Fried | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-MH | Michael Harris II | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures |
| SS-MM | Max Meyer | Miami Marlins | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures |
| SS-OP | Oswald Peraza | New York Yankees | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures |
| SS-PA | Pete Alonso | New York Mets | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-PG | Paul Goldschmidt | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-PM | Paul Molitor | Milwaukee Brewers | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-RD | Reid Detmers | Angels | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-RG | Riley Greene | Detroit Tigers | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures |
| SS-RH | Rhys Hoskins | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-RY | Robin Yount | Milwaukee Brewers | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-SA | Sandy Alcantara | Miami Marlins | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-SS | Spencer Strider | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-TH | Trevor Hoffman | San Diego Padres | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-VG | Vaughn Grissom | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures |
| GG-AJ | Andruw Jones | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-AR | Adley Rutschman | Baltimore Orioles | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs |
| GG-BS | Blake Snell | San Diego Padres | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-BW | Bobby Witt Jr. | Kansas City Royals | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-CC | Corbin Carroll | Arizona Diamondbacks | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs |
| GG-CF | Carlton Fisk | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-CM | Christopher Morel | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs |
| GG-CS | CC Sabathia | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-DP | Dustin Pedroia | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-DS | Dansby Swanson | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-DW | Drew Waters | Kansas City Royals | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs |
| GG-EG | Eric Gagne | Los Angeles Dodgers | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-ET | Ezequiel Tovar | Colorado Rockies | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs |
| GG-FL | Fred Lynn | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-GK | George Kirby | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-JA | Jose Altuve | Houston Astros | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-JB | Jeff Bagwell | Houston Astros | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-JJ | Josh Jung | Texas Rangers | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs |
| GG-JP | Jim Palmer | Baltimore Orioles | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-JR | Julio Rodríguez | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-JV | Joey Votto | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-Jpe Jeremy Peña | Houston Astros | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | ||
| GG-KH | Ke'Bryan Hayes | Pittsburgh Pirates | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-LA | Luis Arraez | Miami Marlins | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-MM | Max Muncy | Los Angeles Dodgers | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-MO | Matt Olson | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-NJ | Nolan Jones | Colorado Rockies | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs |
| GG-NR | Nolan Ryan | California Angels | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-PA | Pete Alonso | New York Mets | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-RS | Ryne Sandberg | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-SB | Shane Bieber | Cleveland Guardians | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-TC | Triston Casas | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs |
| GG-WB | Walker Buehler | Los Angeles Dodgers | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-WC | Will Clark | San Francisco Giants | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| BR-AP | Albert Pujols | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | Baseball Royalty | |
| BR-AR | Alex Rodriguez | Texas Rangers | Autograph | Baseball Royalty | |
| BR-BW | Bobby Witt Jr. | Kansas City Royals | Autograph | Baseball Royalty | |
| BR-CR | Cal Ripken Jr. | Baltimore Orioles | Autograph | Baseball Royalty | |
| BR-DO | David Ortiz | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | Baseball Royalty | |
| BR-JS | Juan Soto | San Diego Padres | Autograph | Baseball Royalty | |
| BR-MS | Mike Schmidt | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | Baseball Royalty | |
| BR-NR | Nolan Ryan | Texas Rangers | Autograph | Baseball Royalty | |
| BR-P | Mike Piazza | New York Mets | Autograph | Baseball Royalty | |
| BR-PG | Paul Goldschmidt | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | Baseball Royalty | |
| DA-BS | Xander Bogaerts / Juan Soto | San Diego Padres | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Autographs | |
| DA-DJ | Paul Goldschmidt / Aaron Judge | St. Louis Cardinals / New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Autographs | |
| DA-HR | Cal Ripken Jr. / Gunnar Henderson | Baltimore Orioles | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR DUAL Autographs |
| DA-IR | Julio Rodríguez / Ichiro | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Autographs | |
| DA-JJ | Aaron Judge / Derek Jeter | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Autographs | |
| DA-MJ | Randy Johnson / Pedro Martinez | Montreal Expos | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Autographs | |
| DA-RO | Shohei Ohtani / Nolan Ryan | Angels / California Angels | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Autographs | |
| DA-TS | Mike Schmidt / Trea Turner | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Autographs | |
| FST-BAW | Brett Baty / Pete Alonso / David Wright | New York Mets | Autograph | FIVE STAR Triple Autographs | |
| FST-BLV | Barry Larkin / Johnny Bench / Joey Votto | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | FIVE STAR Triple Autographs | |
| FST-DSS | Ryne Sandberg / Andre Dawson / Sammy Sosa | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STAR Triple Autographs | |
| FST-GRJ | Chipper Jones / Vaughn Grissom / Austin Riley | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR Triple Autographs | |
| FST-JWJ | Derek Jeter / Aaron Judge / Dave Winfield | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR Triple Autographs | |
| FST-TBS | Xander Bogaerts / Juan Soto / Fernando Tatis Jr. | San Diego Padres | Autograph | FIVE STAR Triple Autographs | |
| FSTA-AMPSG | Nolan Arenado | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSTA-AMPSG | Ozzie Smith | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSTA-AMPSG | Paul Goldschmidt | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSTA-AMPSG | Albert Pujols | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSTA-AMPSG | Mark McGwire | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSTA-DBORF | Manny Ramirez | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSTA-DBORF | David Ortiz | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSTA-DBORF | Wade Boggs | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSTA-DBORF | Carlton Fisk | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSTA-DBORF | Rafael Devers | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSTA-FESHR | Lee Smith | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSTA-FESHR | Mariano Rivera | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSTA-FESHR | Trevor Hoffman | San Diego Padres | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSTA-FESHR | Dennis Eckersley | Oakland Athletics | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSTA-FESHR | Rollie Fingers | Oakland Athletics | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSTA-GMARS | Deion Sanders | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSTA-GMARS | Tom Glavine | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSTA-GMARS | Austin Riley | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSTA-GMARS | Greg Maddux | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSTA-GMARS | Ronald Acuña Jr. | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSTA-PHRCW | Julio Rodríguez | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSTA-PHRCW | Oneil Cruz | Pittsburgh Pirates | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSTA-PHRCW | Jeremy Peña | Houston Astros | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSTA-PHRCW | Bobby WITT Jr. | Kansas City Royals | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSTA-PHRCW | Michael Harris II | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSTA-STRBR | Iván Rodríguez | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSTA-STRBR | Corey Seager | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSTA-STRBR | Mark Teixeira | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSTA-STRBR | Adrian Beltre | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSTA-STRBR | Alex Rodriguez | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSS-AG | Andres Giménez | Cleveland Guardians | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-AJ | Aaron Judge | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-AP | Albert Pujols | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-AR | Adley Rutschman | Baltimore Orioles | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Signatures |
| FSS-ARI | Austin Riley | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-ARIZ | Anthony Rizzo | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-BB | Brett Baty | New York Mets | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Signatures |
| FSS-BW | Bobby Witt Jr. | Kansas City Royals | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-CA | CJ Abrams | Washington Nationals | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-CC | Corbin Carroll | Arizona Diamondbacks | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Signatures |
| FSS-DO | David Ortiz | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-DW | David Wright | New York Mets | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-DWI | Dave Winfield | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-FT | Fernando Tatis Jr. | San Diego Padres | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-FÁ Francisco Alvarez | New York Mets | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-GK | George Kirby | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-GM | Garrett Mitchell | Milwaukee Brewers | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Signatures |
| FSS-GMA | Greg Maddux | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-GMO | Gabriel Moreno | Arizona Diamondbacks | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Signatures |
| FSS-I | Ichiro | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-IR | Iván Rodríguez | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-JA | Jose Altuve | Houston Astros | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-JB | Jeff Bagwell | Houston Astros | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-JC | Jazz Chisholm Jr. | Miami Marlins | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-JG | Jordan Groshans | Miami Marlins | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Signatures |
| FSS-JJ | Josh Jung | Texas Rangers | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Signatures |
| FSS-JP | Jorge Posada | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-JPE | Jeremy Peña | Houston Astros | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-JR | Julio Rodríguez | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-JS | Juan Soto | San Diego Padres | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-MH | Michael Harris II | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Signatures |
| FSS-MM | Max Meyer | Miami Marlins | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Signatures |
| FSS-MMC | Mark McGwire | Oakland Athletics | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-MT | Mike Trout | Angels | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-NG | Nolan Gorman | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Signatures |
| FSS-NP | Nick Pratto | Kansas City Royals | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Signatures |
| FSS-NR | Nolan Ryan | Houston Astros | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-NRY | Nolan Ryan | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-OP | Oswald Peraza | New York Yankees | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Signatures |
| FSS-PA | Pete Alonso | New York Mets | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-PG | Paul Goldschmidt | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-PM | Paul Molitor | Milwaukee Brewers | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-PMA | Pedro Martinez | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-RG | Riley Greene | Detroit Tigers | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Signatures |
| FSS-RH | Rhys Hoskins | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-RJ | Randy Johnson | Montreal Expos | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-SS | Spencer Strider | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-TC | Triston Casas | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Signatures |
| FSS-TO | Tony Oliva | Minnesota Twins | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-TT | Trea Turner | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-VG | Vladimir Guerrero | Angels | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FSS-VGU | Vladimir Guerrero Jr. | Toronto Blue Jays | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FTP-AD | Andre Dawson | Montreal Expos | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-AR | Austin Riley | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-BP | Buster Posey | San Francisco Giants | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-BW | Bobby Witt Jr. | Kansas City Royals | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-CA | CJ Abrams | Washington Nationals | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-CR | Cal Ripken Jr. | Baltimore Orioles | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-CS | Corey Seager | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-CY | Christian Yelich | Milwaukee Brewers | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-HM | Hideki Matsui | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-I | Ichiro | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-J | Bo Jackson | Kansas City Royals | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-JC | Jazz Chisholm Jr. | Miami Marlins | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-JP | Jeremy Peña | Houston Astros | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-JR | José Ramírez | Cleveland Guardians | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-JRO | Julio Rodríguez | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-JS | Juan Soto | San Diego Padres | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-KH | Ke'Bryan Hayes | Pittsburgh Pirates | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-MM | Manny Machado | San Diego Padres | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-MT | Mike Trout | Angels | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-PA | Pete Alonso | New York Mets | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-PG | Paul Goldschmidt | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-PM | Paul Molitor | Milwaukee Brewers | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-RA | Ronald Acuña Jr. | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-RH | Rhys Hoskins | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-RY | Robin Yount | Milwaukee Brewers | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-SO | Shohei Ohtani | Angels | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-TA | Tim Anderson | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-TT | Trea Turner | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-TTU | Trea Turner | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-VG | Vladimir Guerrero | Montreal Expos | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-WB | Wade Boggs | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-XB | Xander Bogaerts | San Diego Padres | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| PP-AG | Andres Giménez | Cleveland Guardians | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-AM | Alek Manoah | Toronto Blue Jays | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-AR | Austin Riley | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-AT | Alek Thomas | Arizona Diamondbacks | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-BS | Blake Snell | San Diego Padres | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-BW | Bobby Witt Jr. | Kansas City Royals | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-CA | CJ Abrams | Washington Nationals | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-CF | Carlton Fisk | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-DE | Dennis Eckersley | Oakland Athletics | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-DW | David Wright | New York Mets | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-GK | George Kirby | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-JC | Jazz Chisholm Jr. | Miami Marlins | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-JP | Jeremy Peña | Houston Astros | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-JR | Julio Rodríguez | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-JRA | José Ramírez | Cleveland Guardians | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-JS | Juan Soto | San Diego Padres | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-KH | Ke'Bryan Hayes | Pittsburgh Pirates | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-KT | Kyle Tucker | Houston Astros | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-MC | Matt Chapman | Toronto Blue Jays | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-MF | Max Fried | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-MM | Mark McGwire | Oakland Athletics | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-MS | Mike Schmidt | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-MT | Mark Teixeira | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-PG | Paul Goldschmidt | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-RD | Reid Detmers | Angels | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-RH | Rhys Hoskins | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-SA | Sandy Alcantara | Miami Marlins | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-SB | Shane Bieber | Cleveland Guardians | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-SS | Spencer Strider | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-TT | Trea Turner | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PP-XB | Xander Bogaerts | San Diego Padres | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship CARDS | |
| PPD-BS | Xander Bogaerts / Juan Soto | San Diego Padres | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Subject Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PPD-GC | Matt Chapman / Vladimir Guerrero Jr. | Toronto Blue Jays | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Subject Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PPD-GR | Andres Giménez / José Ramírez | Cleveland Guardians | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Subject Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PPD-GS | Ozzie Smith / Paul Goldschmidt | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Subject Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PPD-HT | Rhys Hoskins / Trea Turner | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Subject Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PPD-KR | Julio Rodríguez / George Kirby | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Subject Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| FSCS-AK | Al Kaline | Detroit Tigers | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-AP | Andy Pafko | Brooklyn Dodgers | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-AR | Al Rosen | Cleveland | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-ARE | Allie Reynolds | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-BA | Bobby Avila | Cleveland | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-BD | Bill Dickey | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-BF | Bob Feller | Cleveland | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-BFU | Bob Friend | Pittsburgh Pirates | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-BG | Burleigh Grimes | Pittsburgh Pirates | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-BGI | Bob Gibson | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-BH | Billy Herman | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-BL | Bob Lemon | Cleveland | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-BM | Bobby Murcer | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-BME | Billy Martin | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-BR | Babe Ruth | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-BRU | Bob Rush | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-BS | Billy Southworth | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-BSH | Bobby Shantz | Philadelphia Athletics | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-BT | Bobby Thomson | New York Giants | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-CF | Curt Flood | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-CK | Charlie Keller | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-DG | Dick Groat | Pittsburgh Pirates | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-DM | Dale Mitchell | Cleveland | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-DMO | Don Mossi | Detroit Tigers | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-DS | Don Sutton | Los Angeles Dodgers | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-DSN | Duke Snider | Los Angeles Dodgers | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-DZ | Don Zimmer | Brooklyn Dodgers | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-EB | Earl Battey | Minnesota Twins | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-EBA | Ernie Banks | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-EJ | Eddie Joost | Philadelphia Athletics | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-ER | Eddie Robinson | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-ES | Enos Slaughter | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-EY | Ed Yost Washington Senators | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | ||
| FSCS-FF | Ferris Fain | Philadelphia Athletics | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-FL | Freddie Lindstrom | New York Giants | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-GK | George Kell | Detroit Tigers | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-GM | Gil McDougald | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-GP | Gaylord Perry | San Francisco Giants | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-GS | George Sisler St. Louis Browns | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | ||
| FSCS-HA | Hank Aaron | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-HB | Hank Bauer | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-HC | Harry Chiti | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-HE | Hoot Evers | Detroit Tigers | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-HM | Heinie Manush St. Louis Browns | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | ||
| FSCS-HN | Hal Newhouser | Detroit Tigers | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-HS | Hank Sauer | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-JB | Jim Bunning | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-JH | Jesse Haines | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-JJ | Jackie Jensen | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-JM | Joe Morgan | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-JP | Johnny Pesky | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-JS | Johnny Sain Boston Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | ||
| FSCS-JV | Johnny Vander Meer | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-LA | Luis Aparicio | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-LB | Lou Brock | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-LD | Larry Doyle | New York Giants | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-LM | Les Moss St. Louis Browns | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | ||
| FSCS-LO | Lefty O'Doul | New York Giants | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-MB | Mace Brown | Pittsburgh Pirates | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-MG | Mike Garcia | Cleveland | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-MI | Monte Irvin | New York Giants | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-MM | Minnie Miñoso | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-MMA | Marty Marion | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-NF | Nellie Fox | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-PN | Phil Niekro | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-PR | Paul Richards | Detroit Tigers | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-RC | Roberto Clemente | Pittsburgh Pirates | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-RF | Ray Fosse | Oakland Athletics | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-RM | Rube Marquard | New York Giants | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-RR | Red Rolfe | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-RS | Ron Santo | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-RSE | Rip Sewell | Pittsburgh Pirates | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-RW | Rube Walker | Brooklyn Dodgers | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-SC | Stan Coveleski | Cleveland | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-SCH | Spud Chandler | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-SM | Sal Maglie | New York Giants | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-SMU | Stan Musial | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-SR | Sam Rice Washington Senators | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | ||
| FSCS-TG | Tony Gwynn | San Diego Padres | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-TH | Tommy Henrich | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-TJ | Travis Jackson | New York Giants | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-TL | Tommy Lasorda | Brooklyn Dodgers | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-TM | Tug McGraw | New York Mets | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-TS | Tom Seaver | New York Mets | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-VR | Vic Raschi | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-VW | Vic Wertz | Detroit Tigers | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-WM | Wally Moon | Los Angeles Dodgers | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-WMC | Willie McCovey | San Francisco Giants | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-WS | Willie Stargell | Pittsburgh Pirates | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCS-WW | Wes Westrum | New York Giants | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| FSCCS-EP | Elvis Presley | Autograph | FIVE STAR Celebrity CUT Signatures | ||
| FSCCS-GP | George S. Patton | Autograph | FIVE STAR Celebrity CUT Signatures | ||
| FSCCS-HK | Henry Kissinger | Autograph | FIVE STAR Celebrity CUT Signatures | ||
| FSCCS-JC | Jimmy Carter | Autograph | FIVE STAR Celebrity CUT Signatures | ||
| FSCCS-JM | James Madison | Autograph | FIVE STAR Celebrity CUT Signatures | ||
| FSCCS-JP | James K. Polk | Autograph | FIVE STAR Celebrity CUT Signatures | ||
| FSCCS-QE | Queen Elizabeth II | Autograph | FIVE STAR Celebrity CUT Signatures | ||
| FSCCS-RL | Ray Liotta | Autograph | FIVE STAR Celebrity CUT Signatures | ||
| FSCCS-RM | Richard McDonald | Autograph | FIVE STAR Celebrity CUT Signatures | ||
| FSCCS-WR | Walter L. Reed | Autograph | FIVE STAR Celebrity CUT Signatures |