Card # | Player | Team | Type | Rookie | Insert Name |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Atmospheric Jellyfish | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 2 | Awful | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 3 | Banshee of the Badlands | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 4 | Beavershark | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 5 | Big Bird | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 6 | Bigfoot | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 7 | Billdad | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 8 | Billiwhack Monster | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 9 | Black Dog | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 10 | Chibi Bigfoot | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 11 | Chibi Cumberland Dragon | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 12 | Chibi Jackalope | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 13 | Cumberland Dragon | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 14 | Cumberland Spaceman | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 15 | Deer Woman | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 16 | Dragon of Oconto Falls | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 17 | Dublin Lake Monster | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 18 | El Verde Entity | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 19 | Explosive Rabbit | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 20 | Friendly Snowman | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 21 | Frost Elemental | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 22 | Fur Bearing Trout | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 23 | Glastonbury Glawackus | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 24 | Golden Bear | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 25 | Golden Haired Girl | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 26 | Green Clawed Monster | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 27 | Honey Island Swamp Monster | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 28 | Hugag | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 29 | Iowa Dragon | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 30 | Jackalope | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 31 | Janet and Rosetta Van De Voort | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 32 | Joe Magarac | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 33 | John Henry | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 34 | Lizard People | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 35 | Mad Gasser of Mattoon | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 36 | Medford Shmoos | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 37 | Mishipeshu | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 38 | Mogollon Monster | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 39 | Nightmarchers | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 40 | Ohio Grassman | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 41 | Old Man Winter | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 42 | Ozark Howler | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 43 | Pascagoula River Aliens | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 44 | Peninsula Python | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 45 | Phantom Car | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 46 | Pope Lick Monster | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 47 | Radioactive Hornets | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 48 | River Mermaid | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 49 | Rocky | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 50 | Rose Robinson | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 51 | Rubberado | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 52 | Selbyville Swamp Monster | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 53 | Skunk Ape | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 54 | Snipe | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 55 | Snoligoster | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 56 | Spearfinger | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 57 | Spook Light | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 58 | Spring Heeled Jack | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 59 | Stone Man | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 60 | Stone-Eating Gyascutus | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 61 | The Phantom Jogger of Canyon Hill | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 62 | The Pink Mess of Goose Creek Lagoon | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 63 | Unicorn | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 64 | Wampus Cat | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 65 | Weeping Black Angel | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 66 | White Screamer | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 67 | Whitey | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 68 | Woolly Mammoth | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| A1 | Frozen Spirit Sigil | Artifact | Base | Base Cards | |
| A2 | Living Earth Sigil | Artifact | Base | Base Cards | |
| A3 | Midnight Lake Sigil | Artifact | Base | Base Cards | |
| A4 | Scorching Rod Sigil | Artifact | Base | Base Cards | |
| A5 | Starlight Sigil | Artifact | Base | Base Cards | |
| S1 | Germinate | Spell | Base | Base Cards | |
| S2 | Hateful Demise | Spell | Base | Base Cards | |
| S3 | Seafood BBQ | Spell | Base | Base Cards | |
| S4 | Turbo Charge | Spell | Base | Base Cards | |
| S5 | Wilderness | Spell | Base | Base Cards | |
| L1 | Red Ghost Polaroid | Base | Base Cards | ||
| L2 | Spirit Storm | Base | Base Cards | ||
| L3 | Battle over Loveland Castle | Base | Base Cards | ||
| L4 | Cryptid Busters Group | Base | Base Cards | ||
| L5 | Cryptid Cloud Shapes | Base | Base Cards | ||
| L6 | Proton Beam | Base | Base Cards | ||
| L7 | Mothman Frogman Art | Base | Base Cards | ||
| L8 | Sam and Frogman | Base | Base Cards | ||
| L9 | Sam Vs. Bigfoot | Base | Base Cards | ||
| L10 | Frogman’s Reveal | Base | Base Cards | ||
| L11 | Mothman Warps | Base | Base Cards | ||
| L12 | Chapter 3 Cover | Base | Base Cards | ||
| L13 | Chapter 4 Cover | Base | Base Cards | ||
| L14 | Chapter 5 Cover | Base | Base Cards | ||
| L15 | Chapter 6 Cover | Base | Base Cards | ||
| T1 | Topps x Wilderness | Base | Base Cards | ||
| 1-F | Atmospheric Jellyfish | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 2-F | Awful | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 5-F | Big Bird | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 9-F | Black Dog | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 10-F | Chibi Bigfoot | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 13-F | Cumberland Dragon | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 16-F | Dragon of Oconto Falls | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 24-F | Golden Bear | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 25-F | Golden Haired Girl | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 26-F | Green Clawed Monster | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 29-F | Iowa Dragon | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 30-F | Jackalope | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 37-F | Mishipeshu | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 41-F | Old Man Winter | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 43-F | Pascagoula River Aliens | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 49-F | Rocky | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 50-F | Rose Robinson | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 54-F | Snipe | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 55-F | Snoligoster | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 59-F | Stone Man | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 62-F | The Pink Mess of Goose Creek Lagoon | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 64-F | Wampus Cat | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 68-F | Woolly Mammoth | Beastie | Base | Base Cards |