2022 Topps Five Star Baseball introduces Five Stars Autograph Relic Book Cards and Baseball Royalty Autographs, giving the product a stronger multi-player and legend-driven chase than earlier editions. The release remains a compact premium autograph brand built around on-card signatures, dual and triple autographs, Five Tool Phenom Autographs, Pentamerous Penmanship, and jumbo prime relic autos, with cut signatures still in the mix. This checklist file covers 534 total cards, including 478 autographs, 56 autograph relics, and 57 rookies.
Card # | Player | Team | Type | Rookie | Insert Name |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FSJP-AB | Adrian Beltre | Texas Rangers | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-ABR | Alex Bregman | Houston Astros | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-AC | Aroldis Chapman | New York Yankees | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-AJ | Aaron Judge | New York Yankees | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-AR | Austin Riley | Atlanta Braves | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-BB | Bert Blyleven | California Angels | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-BBX | Byron Buxton | Minnesota Twins | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-BD | Bryan De La Cruz | Miami Marlins | autorelic | ✓ | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS |
| FSJP-BL | Brandon Lowe | Tampa Bay Rays | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-BP | Buster Posey | San Francisco Giants | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-CJ | Chipper Jones | Atlanta Braves | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-CR | Cal Ripken Jr. | Baltimore Orioles | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-CS | CC Sabathia | New York Yankees | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-CY | Christian Yelich | Milwaukee Brewers | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-DC | David Cone | New York Mets | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-DO | David Ortiz | Boston Red Sox | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-DS | Dansby Swanson | Atlanta Braves | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-FF | Freddie Freeman | Atlanta Braves | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-FT | Fernando Tatis Jr. | San Diego Padres | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-I | Ichiro | Miami Marlins | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-IR | Ivan Rodriguez | Texas Rangers | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-JA | Jose Abreu | Chicago White Sox | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-JAL | Jose Altuve | Houston Astros | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-JD | Jarren Duran | Boston Red Sox | autorelic | ✓ | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS |
| FSJP-JR | J.T. Realmuto | Philadelphia Phillies | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-JSO | Juan Soto | Washington Nationals | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-JV | Joey Votto | Cincinnati Reds | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-KG | Ken Griffey Jr. | Seattle Mariners | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-KT | Kyle Tucker | Houston Astros | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-MC | Miguel Cabrera | Detroit Tigers | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-MM | Max Muncy | Los Angeles Dodgers | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-MO | Matt Olson | Oakland Athletics | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-MT | Mike Trout | Angels | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-PA | Pete Alonso | New York Mets | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-PG | Paul Goldschmidt | St. Louis Cardinals | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-RAJ | Ronald Acuña Jr. | Atlanta Braves | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-RD | Rafael Devers | Boston Red Sox | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-SO | Shohei Ohtani | Angels | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-SP | Salvador Perez | Kansas City Royals | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-TA | Tim Anderson | Chicago White Sox | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-TH | Teoscar Hernandez | Toronto Blue Jays | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-VG | Vladimir Guerrero Jr. | Toronto Blue Jays | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-WB | Walker Buehler | Los Angeles Dodgers | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-WC | Willson Contreras | Chicago Cubs | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSJP-WF | Wander Franco | Tampa Bay Rays | autorelic | ✓ | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS |
| FSJP-YA | Yordan Alvarez | Houston Astros | autorelic | FIVE STAR Autographed JUMBO PRIME CARDS | |
| FSBC-AABMT | Jose Altuve / Yordan Alvarez / Alex Bregman / Lance McCullers Jr. / Kyle Tucker | Houston Astros | autorelic | FIVE STARS Autograph RELIC BOOK CARDS | |
| FSBC-AFJGM | Tom Glavine / Dale Murphy / Freddie Freeman / Ronald Acuña Jr. / Chipper Jones | Atlanta Braves | autorelic | FIVE STARS Autograph RELIC BOOK CARDS | |
| FSBC-AGMMS | Paul Goldschmidt / Ozzie Smith / Yadier Molina / Mark McGwire / Nolan Arenado | St. Louis Cardinals | autorelic | FIVE STARS Autograph RELIC BOOK CARDS | |
| FSBC-AGOST | Fernando Tatis Jr. / Juan Soto / Shohei Ohtani / Vladimir Guerrero Jr. / Ronald Acuña Jr. | San Diego Padres / Washington Nationals / Angels / Toronto Blue Jays / Atlanta Braves | autorelic | FIVE STARS Autograph RELIC BOOK CARDS | |
| FSBC-BBGHR | Hyun-Jin Ryu / Vladimir Guerrero Jr. / Teoscar Hernandez / Bo Bichette / Jose Berrios | Toronto Blue Jays | autorelic | FIVE STARS Autograph RELIC BOOK CARDS | |
| FSBC-BJRRT | Cal Ripken Jr. / Xander Bogaerts / Derek Jeter / Fernando Tatis Jr. / Alex Rodriguez | Baltimore Orioles / Boston Red Sox / New York Yankees / San Diego Padres / Seattle Mariners | autorelic | FIVE STARS Autograph RELIC BOOK CARDS | |
| FSBC-DGJMS | Sammy Sosa / Mark Grace / Andre Dawson / Greg Maddux / Fergie Jenkins | Chicago Cubs | autorelic | FIVE STARS Autograph RELIC BOOK CARDS | |
| FSBC-JJRCT | Gerrit Cole / Mariano Rivera / Derek Jeter / Gleyber Torres / Aaron Judge | New York Yankees | autorelic | FIVE STARS Autograph RELIC BOOK CARDS | |
| FSBC-TMSHM | Fernando Tatis Jr. / Joe Musgrove / Eric Hosmer / Blake Snell / Manny Machado | San Diego Padres | autorelic | FIVE STARS Autograph RELIC BOOK CARDS | |
| FSBC-TORAW | Jo Adell / Anthony Rendon / Shohei Ohtani / Mike Trout / Jared Walsh | Angels | autorelic | FIVE STARS Autograph RELIC BOOK CARDS | |
| FSA-AA | Aaron Ashby | Milwaukee Brewers | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-AB | Adrian Beltre | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-ALR | Alex Rodriguez | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-AP | Andy Pettitte | Houston Astros | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-AR | Austin Riley | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-BB | Byron Buxton | Minnesota Twins | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-BJ | Bo Jackson | Kansas City Royals | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-BJA | Bo Jackson | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-BL | Barry Larkin | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-BP | Buster Posey | San Francisco Giants | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-BS | Blake Snell | San Diego Padres | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-BW | Bobby Witt Jr. | Kansas City Royals | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-CB | Corbin Burnes | Milwaukee Brewers | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-CJ | Chipper Jones | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-CJA | CJ Abrams | San Diego Padres | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-CM | Chas McCormick | Houston Astros | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-CR | Cal Ripken Jr. | Baltimore Orioles | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-CRA | Cal Raleigh | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-CS | CC Sabathia | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-CT | Curtis Terry | Minnesota Twins | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-CYZ | Carl Yastrzemski | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-DC | Dylan Carlson | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-DJE | Derek Jeter | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-DLC | Bryan De La Cruz | Miami Marlins | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-DM | Don Mattingly | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-DO | David Ortiz | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-DS | Deion Sanders | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-DW | Dave Winfield | Minnesota Twins | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-DWR | David Wright | New York Mets | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-EJ | Eloy Jimenez | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-EM | Eddie Murray | Baltimore Orioles | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-ER | Emmanuel Rivera | Kansas City Royals | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-FJ | Fergie Jenkins | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-FTH | Frank Thomas | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-GM | Greg Maddux | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-GMX | Greg Maddux | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-GSH | Gavin Sheets | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-HGR | Hunter Greene | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-HP | Hoy Park | Pittsburgh Pirates | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-I | Ichiro | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-IR | Ivan Rodriguez | Florida Marlins | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-JA | Jose Abreu | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-JBE | Johnny Bench | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-JBR | Jose Berrios | Toronto Blue Jays | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-JBU | Jake Burger | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-JC | Jake Cousins | Milwaukee Brewers | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-JD | Jarren Duran | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-JG | Josiah Gray | Washington Nationals | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-JK | Jackson Kowar | Kansas City Royals | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-JL | Josh Lowe | Tampa Bay Rays | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-JME | Jake Meyers | Houston Astros | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-JP | Jeremy Peña | Houston Astros | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-JR | Jose Ramirez | Cleveland Guardians | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-JRE | Jakson Reetz | Milwaukee Brewers | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-JRI | Jim Rice | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-JRY | Joe Ryan | Minnesota Twins | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-JS | John Smoltz | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-JUR | Julio Rodriguez | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-JV | Joey Votto | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-KM | Kyle Muller | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-LG | Luis Gil | New York Yankees | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-LN | Lars Nootbaar | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-LW | Luke Williams | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-MAM | Mark McGwire | Oakland Athletics | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-MAR | Juan Marichal | San Francisco Giants | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-MC | Miguel Cabrera | Detroit Tigers | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-MCH | Matt Chapman | Toronto Blue Jays | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-MM | Mark McGwire | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-MMA | Matt Manning | Detroit Tigers | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-MO | Matt Olson | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-MP | Mike Piazza | New York Mets | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-MR | Mariano Rivera | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-MT | Mike Trout | Angels | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-MTX | Mark Teixeira | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-MV | Matt Vierling | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-NA | Nolan Arenado | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-NG | Nomar Garciaparra | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-NR | Nolan Ryan | Houston Astros | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-OC | Oneil Cruz | Pittsburgh Pirates | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-OS | Ozzie Smith | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-PA | Pete Alonso | New York Mets | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-PG | Paul Goldschmidt | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-PMA | Patrick Mazeika | New York Mets | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-PO | Paul O'Neill | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-RA | Randy Arozarena | Tampa Bay Rays | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-RAD | Riley Adams | Washington Nationals | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-RAJ | Ronald Acuña Jr. | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-RC | Rodolfo Castro | Pittsburgh Pirates | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-RDA | Ronnie Dawson | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-RDE | Reid Detmers | Angels | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-RJO | Randy Johnson | Arizona Diamondbacks | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-ROD | Rod Carew | Minnesota Twins | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-RS | Ryne Sandberg | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-RV | Ryan Vilade | Colorado Rockies | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-RY | Robin Yount | Milwaukee Brewers | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-SC | Steve Carlton | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-SF | Stuart Fairchild | Arizona Diamondbacks | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-ST | Spencer Torkelson | Detroit Tigers | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-STR | Darryl Strawberry | New York Mets | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-TEK | Jason Varitek | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-TM | Tylor Megill | New York Mets | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-TP | Tony Pérez | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-TS | Tony Santillan | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-VB | Vidal Brujan | Tampa Bay Rays | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-VG | Vladimir Guerrero | Montreal Expos | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-VGJ | Vladimir Guerrero Jr. | Toronto Blue Jays | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-WB | Wade Boggs | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-WC | Will Clark | San Francisco Giants | Autograph | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs | |
| FSA-WF | Wander Franco | Tampa Bay Rays | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| FSA-ZS | Zack Short | Detroit Tigers | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR BASE Autographs |
| SS-AC | Aroldis Chapman | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-AD | Andre Dawson | Montreal Expos | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-AM | Austin Meadows | Tampa Bay Rays | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-BA | Bobby Abreu | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-BW | Bernie Williams | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-CB | Corbin Burnes | Milwaukee Brewers | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-CK | Corey Kluber | Tampa Bay Rays | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-CS | Corey Seager | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-DE | Dennis Eckersley | Oakland Athletics | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-DM | Dale Murphy | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-EJ | Eloy Jimenez | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-EM | Edgar Martinez | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-FH | Felix Hernandez | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-FT | Frank Thomas | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-JA | Jose Abreu | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-JB | Jeff Bagwell | Houston Astros | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-JI | Jonathan India | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-KBH | Ke'Bryan Hayes | Pittsburgh Pirates | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-LS | Lee Smith | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-LW | Larry Walker | Colorado Rockies | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-MM | Max Muncy | Los Angeles Dodgers | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-MS | Marcus Semien | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-MY | Mike Yastrzemski | San Francisco Giants | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-OS | Ozzie Smith | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-PAL | Pete Alonso | New York Mets | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-PK | Paul Konerko | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-SG | Sonny Gray | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-TG | Tom Glavine | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-TR | Tim Raines | Montreal Expos | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-WB | Walker Buehler | Los Angeles Dodgers | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| SS-YG | Yasmani Grandal | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR Silver Signatures | |
| GG-AB | Adrian Beltre | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-AG | Adolis Garcia | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-BZ | Barry Zito | Oakland Athletics | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-CD | Carlos Delgado | Toronto Blue Jays | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-CF | Carlton Fisk | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-DC | Dylan Carlson | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-DM | Don Mattingly | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-DS | Darryl Strawberry | New York Mets | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-DW | David Wright | New York Mets | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-FL | Fred Lynn | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-JB | Johnny Bench | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-JC | Jose Canseco | Oakland Athletics | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-JF | Jack Flaherty | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-JG | Juan Gonzalez | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-JP | Jim Palmer | Baltimore Orioles | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-JR | J.T. Realmuto | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-JV | Jason Varitek | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-KL | Kyle Lewis | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-KT | Kyle Tucker | Houston Astros | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-MC | Matt Chapman | Oakland Athletics | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-MV | Mo Vaughn | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-NC | Nelson Cruz | Tampa Bay Rays | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-OA | Ozzie Albies | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-PMO | Paul Molitor | Minnesota Twins | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-RH | Ryan Howard | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-RR | Robbie Ray | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-SR | Scott Rolen | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-TH | Torii Hunter | Angels | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-WM | Whit Merrifield | Kansas City Royals | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| GG-YA | Yordan Alvarez | Houston Astros | Autograph | FIVE STAR Golden Graphs | |
| BR-BP | Buster Posey | San Francisco Giants | Autograph | Baseball Royalty Autographs | |
| BR-DJ | Derek Jeter | New York Yankees | Autograph | Baseball Royalty Autographs | |
| BR-GM | Greg Maddux | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | Baseball Royalty Autographs | |
| BR-I | Ichiro | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | Baseball Royalty Autographs | |
| BR-MC | Miguel Cabrera | Detroit Tigers | Autograph | Baseball Royalty Autographs | |
| BR-MR | Mariano Rivera | New York Yankees | Autograph | Baseball Royalty Autographs | |
| BR-MT | Mike Trout | Angels | Autograph | Baseball Royalty Autographs | |
| BR-NR | Nolan Ryan | Texas Rangers | Autograph | Baseball Royalty Autographs | |
| BR-RA | Ronald Acuña Jr. | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | Baseball Royalty Autographs | |
| BR-RJ | Randy Johnson | Arizona Diamondbacks | Autograph | Baseball Royalty Autographs | |
| BR-SO | Shohei Ohtani | Angels | Autograph | Baseball Royalty Autographs | |
| BR-VG | Vladimir Guerrero Jr. | Toronto Blue Jays | Autograph | Baseball Royalty Autographs | |
| DA-BV | Johnny Bench / Joey Votto | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Autographs | |
| DA-GT | Vladimir Guerrero / Vladimir Guerrero Jr. | Montreal Expos / Toronto Blue Jays | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Autographs | |
| DA-HT | Mike Trout / Bryce Harper | Angels / Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Autographs | |
| DA-IG | Ken Griffey Jr. / Ichiro | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Autographs | |
| DA-JR | Mariano Rivera / Derek Jeter | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Autographs | |
| DA-MG | Paul Goldschmidt / Mark McGwire | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Autographs | |
| DA-MO | Pedro Martinez / David Ortiz | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Autographs | |
| DA-MR | Eddie Murray / Cal Ripken Jr. | Baltimore Orioles | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Autographs | |
| DA-PA | Pete Alonso / Mike Piazza | New York Mets | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Autographs | |
| DA-TG | Vladimir Guerrero Jr. / Fernando Tatis Jr. | Toronto Blue Jays / San Diego Padres | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Autographs | |
| DA-TO | Mike Trout / Shohei Ohtani | Angels | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Autographs | |
| FST-AFR | Austin Riley / Ronald Acuña Jr. / Freddie Freeman | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR Triple Autographs | |
| FST-BAA | Alex Bregman / Jose Altuve / Yordan Alvarez | Houston Astros | Autograph | FIVE STAR Triple Autographs | |
| FST-DMS | Andre Dawson / Ryne Sandberg / Greg Maddux | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STAR Triple Autographs | |
| FST-JRT | Derek Jeter / Fernando Tatis Jr. / Cal Ripken Jr. | New York Yankees / San Diego Padres / Baltimore Orioles | Autograph | FIVE STAR Triple Autographs | |
| FST-MSG | Paul Goldschmidt / Ozzie Smith / Mark McGwire | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR Triple Autographs | |
| FST-RCP | Roger Clemens / Andy Pettitte / Mariano Rivera | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR Triple Autographs | |
| FST-ROT | Mike Trout / Nolan Ryan / Shohei Ohtani | Angels / California Angels / Angels | Autograph | FIVE STAR Triple Autographs | |
| FST-TKA | Paul Konerko / Jose Abreu / Frank Thomas | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR Triple Autographs | |
| FST-YOD | Carl Yastrzemski / Rafael Devers / David Ortiz | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR Triple Autographs | |
| FSA-AP1 | AlbertPujols | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-AP1 | MarkMcGwire | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-AP1 | LouBrock | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-AP1 | OzzieSmith | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-AP1 | PaulGoldschmidt | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-FT1 | FernandoTatis Jr. | San Diego Padres | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-FT1 | DaveWinfield | San Diego Padres | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-FT1 | TrevorHoffman | San Diego Padres | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STARS Autographs |
| FSA-FT1 | MannyMachado | San Diego Padres | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-FT1 | BlakeSnell | San Diego Padres | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-RSA | RyneSandberg | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-RSA | BillyWilliams | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STARS Autographs |
| FSA-RSA | RonSanto | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-RSA | GregMaddux | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-RSA | FergieJenkins | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-CY | CarlYastrzemski | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-CY | DavidOrtiz | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-CY | PedroMartinez | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-CY | MannyRamirez | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-CY | JasonVaritek | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-KG1 | KenGriffey Jr. | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-KG1 | Ichiro | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-KG1 | RandyJohnson | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-KG1 | AlexRodriguez | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-KG1 | EdgarMartinez | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-MT2 | MikeTrout | Angels | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-MT2 | KenGriffey Jr. | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-MT2 | DerekJeter | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-MT2 | AlbertPujols | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-MT2 | BryceHarper | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-FF | FreddieFreeman | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-FF | RonaldAcuña Jr. | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STARS Autographs |
| FSA-FF | OzzieAlbies | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-FF | AustinRiley | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-FF | DansbySwanson | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-AR3 | AlexRodriguez | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-AR3 | CoreySeager | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-AR3 | AdrianBeltre | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-AR3 | IvanRodriguez | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-AR3 | MarcusSemien | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-DJ3 | DerekJeter | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-DJ3 | FernandoTatis Jr. | San Diego Padres | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-DJ3 | WanderFranco | Tampa Bay Rays | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-DJ3 | CalRipken Jr. | Baltimore Orioles | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-DJ3 | AlexRodriguez | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-WF2 | WanderFranco | Tampa Bay Rays | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-WF2 | BobbyWitt Jr. | Kansas City Royals | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-WF2 | JulioRodriguez | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-WF2 | JeremyPena | Houston Astros | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-WF2 | SpencerTorkelson | Detroit Tigers | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STARS Autographs |
| FSA-VG1 | VladimirGuerrero Jr. | Toronto Blue Jays | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STARS Autographs |
| FSA-VG1 | BoBichette | Toronto Blue Jays | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STARS Autographs |
| FSA-VG1 | TeoscarHernandez | Toronto Blue Jays | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STARS Autographs |
| FSA-VG1 | JoseBerrios | Toronto Blue Jays | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STARS Autographs |
| FSA-VG1 | Hyun-JinRyu | Toronto Blue Jays | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STARS Autographs |
| FSA-RWGTG | JulioRodriguez | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-RWGTG | BobbyWitt Jr. | Kansas City Royals | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-RWGTG | HunterGreene | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-RWGTG | SpencerTorkelson | Detroit Tigers | Autograph | FIVE STARS Autographs | |
| FSA-RWGTG | MacKenzieGore | San Diego Padres | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STARS Autographs |
| FS-AB | Adrian Beltre | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-ABR | Alex Bregman | Houston Astros | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-AR | Anthony Rizzo | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-BH | Bryce Harper | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-BJ | Bo Jackson | Kansas City Royals | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-BP | Buster Posey | San Francisco Giants | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-BS | Blake Snell | San Diego Padres | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-CB | Cody Bellinger | Los Angeles Dodgers | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-CJ | Chipper Jones | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-CR | Cal Ripken Jr. | Baltimore Orioles | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-CY | Christian Yelich | Milwaukee Brewers | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-DS | Deion Sanders | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-DW | Dave Winfield | Minnesota Twins | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-EM | Eddie Murray | Baltimore Orioles | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-FT | Frank Thomas | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-GM | Greg Maddux | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-HM | Hideki Matsui | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-JA | Jose Abreu | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-JAL | Jose Altuve | Houston Astros | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-JB | Johnny Bench | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-JDM | J.D. Martinez | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-JV | Joey Votto | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-LR | Luis Robert | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-LW | Larry Walker | Colorado Rockies | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-MC | Miguel Cabrera | Detroit Tigers | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-MM | Manny Machado | San Diego Padres | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-MMC | Mark McGwire | Oakland Athletics | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-MR | Mariano Rivera | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-MS | Mike Schmidt | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-NA | Nolan Arenado | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-NR | Nolan Ryan | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-NRY | Nolan Ryan | Houston Astros | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-PA | Pete Alonso | New York Mets | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-PG | Paul Goldschmidt | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-RA | Ronald Acuña Jr. | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-RC | Roger Clemens | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-RH | Rhys Hoskins | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-RJ | Randy Johnson | Arizona Diamondbacks | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-RS | Ryne Sandberg | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-RY | Robin Yount | Milwaukee Brewers | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-SO | Shohei Ohtani | Angels | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-VG | Vladimir Guerrero | Montreal Expos | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-WB | Wade Boggs | Tampa Bay Devil Rays | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-WBU | Walker Buehler | Los Angeles Dodgers | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-WC | Willson Contreras | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FS-YAS | Carl Yastrzemski | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR Signatures | |
| FTP-AD | Andre Dawson | Montreal Expos | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-BB | Byron Buxton | Minnesota Twins | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-BH | Bryce Harper | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-CS | Corey Seager | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-CY | Christian Yelich | Milwaukee Brewers | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-DW | Dave Winfield | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-EJ | Eloy Jimenez | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-I | Ichiro | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-JA | Jose Altuve | Houston Astros | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-JR | Jose Ramirez | Cleveland Guardians | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-JV | Joey Votto | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-LR | Luis Robert | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-MS | Marcus Semien | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-MSC | Mike Schmidt | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-MT | Mike Trout | Angels | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-PA | Pete Alonso | New York Mets | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-PAL | Pete Alonso | New York Mets | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-RAJ | Ronald Acuña Jr. | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-RD | Rafael Devers | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-RH | Rhys Hoskins | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-RY | Robin Yount | Milwaukee Brewers | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-RYO | Robin Yount | Milwaukee Brewers | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-SO | Shohei Ohtani | Angels | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-SS | Sammy Sosa | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| FTP-VG | Vladimir Guerrero Jr. | Toronto Blue Jays | Autograph | FIVE TOOL Phenom Autographs | |
| PP-BD | Bryan De La Cruz | Miami Marlins | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship |
| PP-CB | Corbin Burnes | Milwaukee Brewers | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PP-CY | Christian Yelich | Milwaukee Brewers | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PP-CYA | Carl Yastrzemski | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PP-EM | Eddie Murray | Baltimore Orioles | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PP-IR | Ivan Rodriguez | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PP-JA | Jose Altuve | Houston Astros | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PP-JD | Jarren Duran | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | ✓ | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship |
| PP-JR | Jose Ramirez | Cleveland Guardians | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PP-JS | Juan Soto | Washington Nationals | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PP-JV | Joey Votto | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PP-KT | Kyle Tucker | Houston Astros | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PP-LR | Luis Robert | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PP-MC | Miguel Cabrera | Detroit Tigers | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PP-MM | Mark McGwire | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PP-MO | Matt Olson | Oakland Athletics | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PP-MP | Mike Piazza | New York Mets | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PP-NA | Nolan Arenado | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PP-NR | Nolan Ryan | California Angels | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PP-PA | Pete Alonso | New York Mets | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PP-RA | Randy Arozarena | Tampa Bay Rays | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PP-RJO | Randy Johnson | Arizona Diamondbacks | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PP-SB | Shane Bieber | Cleveland Guardians | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PP-SP | Salvador Perez | Kansas City Royals | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PP-VG | Vladimir Guerrero | Montreal Expos | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PP-VGJ | Vladimir Guerrero Jr. | Toronto Blue Jays | Autograph | FIVE STAR Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PPD-GG | Vladimir Guerrero Jr. / Vladimir Guerrero | Toronto Blue Jays / Montreal Expos | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Subject Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PPD-IG | Ichiro / Ken Griffey Jr. | Seattle Mariners | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Subject Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PPD-JR | Chipper Jones / Austin Riley | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Subject Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PPD-MG | Paul Goldschmidt / Mark McGwire | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Subject Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PPD-OR | Manny Ramirez / David Ortiz | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Subject Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PPD-PA | Mike Piazza / Pete Alonso | New York Mets | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Subject Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PPD-SS | Marcus Semien / Corey Seager | Texas Rangers | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Subject Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| PPD-TO | Shohei Ohtani / Mike Trout | Angels | Autograph | FIVE STAR DUAL Subject Pentamerous Penmanship | |
| CS-AK1 | Al Kaline | Detroit Tigers | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-AK2 | Al Kaline | Detroit Tigers | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-AL | Al Lopez | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-AP | Andy Pafko | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-BBO | Bobby Bonds | San Francisco Giants | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-BBU | Bill Buckner | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-BD | Bobby Doerr | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-BF | Bob Feller | Cleveland | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-BG | Bob Gibson | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-BH | Billy Herman | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-BK | Bowie Kuhn | Major League Baseball | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-BL | Bob Lemon | Cleveland | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-BLE | Buck Leonard | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | ||
| CS-BM | Bobby Murcer | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-BR | Babe Ruth | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-BT | Bobby Thomson | New York Giants | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-CB | James Cool Papa Bell | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | ||
| CS-CF | Curt Flood | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-CH | Carl Hubbell | New York Giants | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-CS | Casey Stengel | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-D | Joe DiMaggio | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-DA | Dick Allen | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-DDE | Dizzy Dean | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-DDR | Don Drysdale | Los Angeles Dodgers | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-DS | Duke Snider | Brooklyn Dodgers | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-DZ | Don Zimmer | Brooklyn Dodgers | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-EA | Earl Averill | Cleveland | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-EB | Ernie Banks | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-EBA | Earl Battey | Minnesota Twins | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-EW | Early Wynn | Cleveland | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-EWE | Earl Weaver | Baltimore Orioles | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-FR1 | Frank Robinson | Baltimore Orioles | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-FR2 | Frank Robinson | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-FR3 | Frank Robinson | California Angels | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-GC1 | Gary Carter | New York Mets | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-GC2 | Gary Carter | Montreal Expos | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-GH | Gil Hodges | Brooklyn Dodgers | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-GKE | George Kell | Detroit Tigers | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-GKEL | George Kelly | Detroit Tigers | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-GS | George Sisler Washington Senators | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | ||
| CS-HA1 | Hank Aaron | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-HA2 | Hank Aaron | Milwaukee Brewers | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-HA3 | Hank Aaron | Milwaukee Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-HC | Harry Caray | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-HCH | Happy Chandler | Major League Baseball | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-HH | Harry Hooper | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-HK1 | Harmon Killebrew | Minnesota Twins | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-HK2 | Harmon Killebrew Washington Senators | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | ||
| CS-JB | Jim Bunning | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-JBU | Jack Buck | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-JH | Jim Catfish Hunter | Oakland Athletics | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-JMI | Johnny Mize | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-JMO1 | Joe Morgan | Houston Astros | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-JMO2 | Joe Morgan | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-JN | Joe Niekro | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-JS | Joe Sewell | Cleveland | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-JW | Smoky Joe Wood | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-KP | Kirby Puckett | Minnesota Twins | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-L | Don Larsen | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-LA | Luke Appling | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-LBO | Lou Boudreau | Cleveland | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-LBR1 | Lou Brock | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-LBR2 | Lou Brock | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-LD | Larry Doby | Cleveland | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-LGO | Lefty Gomez | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-LGR | Lefty Grove | Philadelphia Athletics | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-MI | Monte Irvin | New York Giants | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-MM | Minnie Minoso | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-MO | Mel Ott | New York Giants | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-MP | Milt Pappas | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-NF | Nellie Fox | Chicago White Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-PN | Phil Niekro | Atlanta Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-PR | Phil Rizzuto | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-PW | Pee Wee Reese | Brooklyn Dodgers | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-RA | Richie Ashburn | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-RC | Roy Campanella | Brooklyn Dodgers | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-RFE | Rick Ferrell | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-RFO | Ray Fosse | Oakland Athletics | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-RH1 | Rogers Hornsby | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-RH2 | Rogers Hornsby | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-RK | Ralph Kiner | Pittsburgh Pirates | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-RRO | Robin Roberts | Philadelphia Phillies | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-RRU | Red Ruffing | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-RSA | Ron Santo | Chicago Cubs | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-SA | Sparky Anderson | Cincinnati Reds | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-SM | Stan Musial | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-SP | Satchel Paige St. Louis Browns | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | ||
| CS-TG | Tony Gwynn | San Diego Padres | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-TL | Tommy Lasorda | Los Angeles Dodgers | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-TSE | Tom Seaver | New York Mets | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-TSP | Tris Speaker | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-TW | Ted Williams | Boston Red Sox | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-WF | Whitey Ford | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-WH | Whitey Herzog | St. Louis Cardinals | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-WM | Willie McCovey | San Francisco Giants | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-WS1 | Warren Spahn | Milwaukee Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-WS2 | Warren Spahn Boston Braves | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | ||
| CS-WST1 | Willie Stargell | Pittsburgh Pirates | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-WST2 | Willie Stargell | Pittsburgh Pirates | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CS-YB | Yogi Berra | New York Yankees | Autograph | FIVE STAR CUT Signatures | |
| CCS-BO | Barack Obama | Autograph | FIVE STAR Celebrity CUT Signatures | ||
| CCS-BW | Betty White | Autograph | FIVE STAR Celebrity CUT Signatures | ||
| CCS-CB | Chadwick Boseman | Autograph | FIVE STAR Celebrity CUT Signatures | ||
| CCS-EH | Sir Edmund Hillary | Autograph | FIVE STAR Celebrity CUT Signatures | ||
| CCS-GB | George W. Bush | Autograph | FIVE STAR Celebrity CUT Signatures | ||
| CCS-KB | Kobe Bryant | Autograph | FIVE STAR Celebrity CUT Signatures | ||
| CCS-PW | Paul Walker | Autograph | FIVE STAR Celebrity CUT Signatures | ||
| CCS-RR | Ronald Reagan | Autograph | FIVE STAR Celebrity CUT Signatures | ||
| CCS-TR | Theodore Roosevelt | Autograph | FIVE STAR Celebrity CUT Signatures | ||
| CCS-WW | Woodrow Wilson | Autograph | FIVE STAR Celebrity CUT Signatures |