Card # | Player | Team | Type | Rookie | Insert Name |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Agropelter | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 2 | Alien Astronaut | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 3 | Babe the Blue Ox | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 4 | Batsquatch | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 5 | Beast of Busco | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 6 | Bigfoot | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 7 | Black Cat | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 8 | Bunny Man | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 9 | Cactus Cat | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 10 | Chessie | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 11 | Chibi Mothman | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 12 | Chibi Quetza | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 13 | Chupacabra | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 14 | Dingbelle | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 15 | Enfield Monster | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 16 | Flatwoods Monster | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 17 | Fresno Nightcrawlers | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 18 | Frozen People | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 19 | Funeral Mountain Terrashot | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 20 | Gee-Gee Bird | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 21 | Ghost Deer | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 22 | Ghost Train | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 23 | Giant Salamander | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 24 | Gumberoo | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 25 | Hide Behind | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 26 | Hodag | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 27 | Hoop Snake | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 28 | Hopkinsville Goblin | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 29 | Huggin' Molly | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 30 | Jersey Devil | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 31 | Joint Snake | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 32 | Kentucky Hellhound | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 33 | Killer Clown | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 34 | Kushtaka | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 35 | Lake Worth Monster | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 36 | Lava Bear | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 37 | Lizard Man of Scape Ore Swamp | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 38 | Loveland Frogman | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 39 | Mantis Man | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 40 | Matlox | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 41 | Menehune | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 42 | Metal Man of Alabama | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 43 | Minnesota Iceman | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 44 | Moon-eyed People | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 45 | Mothman | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 46 | Old Green Eyes | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 47 | Piasa Bird | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 48 | Pukwudgie | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 49 | Quetzalcoatlus | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 50 | River Dinos | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 51 | Roperite | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 52 | Rumptifusel | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 53 | Salem's Witches | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 54 | Sam Sinclair | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 55 | Sewer Alligator | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 56 | Shadow People | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 57 | Sinkhole Sam | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 58 | Slide-Rock Bolter | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 59 | Sliver Cat | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 60 | Snallygaster | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 61 | Snow Snake | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 62 | Snow Wasset | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 63 | Space Penguins | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 64 | Squonk | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 65 | Terror Bird | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 66 | The Char Man | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 67 | The Spookster | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 68 | Tizheruk | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 69 | Tripodero | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 70 | Uncle Sam | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 71 | Walking Sam | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 72 | Wapaloosie | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| 73 | White Thang | Beastie | Base | Base Cards | |
| C1 | Michael Waddell Creator Card Caster | Gold | Base | Base Cards | |
| C2 | Steve Aoki Creator Card Caster | Gold | Base | Base Cards | |
| P1 | Topps X Cryptid Nation Collab Promo | Gold | Base | Base Cards | |
| L1 | Young Power | Lore | Base | Base Cards | |
| L2 | Childhood's End | Lore | Base | Base Cards | |
| L3 | Georgetown | Lore | Base | Base Cards | |
| L4 | Roadside Diner | Lore | Base | Base Cards | |
| L5 | Chapter 1 Cover | Lore | Base | Base Cards | |
| L6 | Chapter 2 Cover | Lore | Base | Base Cards | |
| L7 | Contracted | Lore | Base | Base Cards | |
| L8 | Radio Silence | Lore | Base | Base Cards | |
| L9 | Midnight's Escape | Lore | Base | Base Cards | |
| L10 | Quantum Power | Lore | Base | Base Cards | |
| 3-G | Babe the Blue Ox | Sighting | Base | Base Cards | |
| 5-G | Beast of Busco | Sighting | Base | Base Cards | |
| 6-G | Bigfoot | Sighting | Base | Base Cards | |
| 10-G | Chessie | Sighting | Base | Base Cards | |
| 13-G | Chupacabra | Sighting | Base | Base Cards | |
| 16-G | Flatwoods Monster | Sighting | Base | Base Cards | |
| 17-G | Fresno Nightcrawlers | Sighting | Base | Base Cards | |
| 22-G | Ghost Train | Sighting | Base | Base Cards | |
| 26-G | Hodag | Sighting | Base | Base Cards | |
| 30-G | Jersey Devil | Sighting | Base | Base Cards | |
| 37-G | Lizard Man of Scape Ore Swamp | Sighting | Base | Base Cards | |
| 38-G | Loveland Frogman | Sighting | Base | Base Cards | |
| 42-G | Metal Man of Alabama | Sighting | Base | Base Cards | |
| 45-G | Mothman | Sighting | Base | Base Cards | |
| 47-G | Piasa Bird | Sighting | Base | Base Cards | |
| 49-G | Quetzacoatlus | Sighting | Base | Base Cards | |
| 54-G | Sam Sinclair | Sighting | Base | Base Cards | |
| 57-G | Sinkhole Sam | Sighting | Base | Base Cards | |
| 58-G | Slide-Rock Bolter | Sighting | Base | Base Cards | |
| 60-G | Snallygaster | Sighting | Base | Base Cards | |
| 68-G | Tizheruk | Sighting | Base | Base Cards | |
| 70-G | Uncle Sam | Sighting | Base | Base Cards | |
| 71-G | Walking Sam | Sighting | Base | Base Cards |