Card # | Player | Team | Type | Rookie | Insert Name |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| R-1 | Adam Cole | NXT | Insert | Roster | |
| R-2 | Akam | NXT CALLED UP | Insert | Roster | |
| R-3 | Aleister Black | NXT | Insert | Roster | |
| R-4 | Alexander Wolfe | NXT CALLED UP | Insert | Roster | |
| R-5 | Andrade Cien Almas | NXT CALLED UP | Insert | Roster | |
| R-6 | Angelo Dawkins | NXT | Insert | Roster | |
| R-7 | Bobby Fish | NXT | Insert | Roster | |
| R-8 | Buddy Murphy | NXT CALLED UP | Insert | Roster | |
| R-9 | Cezar Bononi | 1ST NXT CARD | Insert | Roster | |
| R-10 | Drew McIntyre | NXT CALLED UP | Insert | Roster | |
| R-11 | Eric Young | NXT CALLED UP | Insert | Roster | |
| R-12 | Fabian Aichner | 1ST NXT CARD | Insert | Roster | |
| R-13 | Gabriel Ealy | NXT | Insert | Roster | |
| R-14 | Kassius Ohno | NXT | Insert | Roster | |
| R-15 | Killian Dain | NXT CALLED UP | Insert | Roster | |
| R-16 | Kyle O'Reilly | NXT | Insert | Roster | |
| R-17 | Lars Sullivan | NXT | Insert | Roster | |
| R-18 | Lio Rush | NXT CALLED UP | Insert | Roster | |
| R-19 | Montez Ford | NXT | Insert | Roster | |
| R-20 | Nick Miller | NXT | Insert | Roster | |
| R-21 | NO WAY Jose | NXT CALLED UP | Insert | Roster | |
| R-22 | Oney Lorcan | NXT | Insert | Roster | |
| R-23 | Otis Dozovic | NXT | Insert | Roster | |
| R-24 | Paul Ellering | NXT | Insert | Roster | |
| R-25 | Pete Dunne | NXT | Insert | Roster | |
| R-26 | Rezar | NXT CALLED UP | Insert | Roster | |
| R-27 | Riddick Moss | NXT | Insert | Roster | |
| R-28 | Roderick Strong | NXT | Insert | Roster | |
| R-29 | Shane Thorne | NXT | Insert | Roster | |
| R-30 | Tino Sabbatelli | NXT | Insert | Roster | |
| R-31 | Tommaso Ciampa | NXT | Insert | Roster | |
| R-32 | Tucker Knight | NXT | Insert | Roster | |
| R-33 | Tyler Bate | NXT | Insert | Roster | |
| R-34 | Trent Seven | NXT | Insert | Roster | |
| R-35 | Velveteen Dream | NXT | Insert | Roster | |
| R-36 | Wesley Blake | NXT | Insert | Roster | |
| R-37 | Aliyah | NXT | Insert | Roster | |
| R-38 | Bianca Belair | 1ST NXT CARD | Insert | Roster | |
| R-39 | Billie Kay | NXT CALLED UP | Insert | Roster | |
| R-40 | Ember Moon | NXT CALLED UP | Insert | Roster | |
| R-41 | Kairi Sane | NXT | Insert | Roster | |
| R-42 | Lacey Evans | 1ST NXT CARD | Insert | Roster | |
| R-43 | Nikki Cross | NXT | Insert | Roster | |
| R-44 | Peyton Royce | NXT CALLED UP | Insert | Roster | |
| R-45 | Shayna Baszler | 1ST NXT CARD | Insert | Roster | |
| R-46 | Taynara Conti | 1ST NXT CARD | Insert | Roster | |
| R-47 | Vanessa Borne | 1ST NXT CARD | Insert | Roster | |
| R-48 | Zelina Vega | NXT CALLED UP | Insert | Roster | |
| R-49 | William Regal | NXT | Insert | Roster | |
| R-50 | Triple H | NXT | Insert | Roster | |
| 1 | Samoa Joe Defeats Mojo Rawley | WWE NXT | Insert | Matches And Moments | |
| 2 | Bobby Roode Defeats Andrade Cien Almas in his NXT | Debut NXT | Insert | Matches And Moments | |
| 3 | The Revival Defeat Johnny Gargano & Tommaso | Ciampa | Insert | Matches And Moments | |
| 4 | Shinsuke Nakamura Defeats Samoa Joe for the NXT | Championship | Insert | Matches And Moments | |
| 5 | The Authors of Pain Defeat TM61 | WWE NXT | Insert | Matches And Moments | |
| 6 | Tye Dillinger Defeats Buddy Murphy | WWE NXT | Insert | Matches And Moments | |
| 7 | Bobby Roode Defeats No Way Jose | WWE NXT | Insert | Matches And Moments | |
| 8 | Andrade Cien Almas Turns on Cedric Alexander WWE NXT | Insert | Matches And Moments | ||
| 9 | SAnitY Debut, Defeating Bobby Roode & Tye Dillinger | WWE NXT | Insert | Matches And Moments | |
| 10 | #DIY Advance to the Second Round of the Dusty Rhodes | WWE TagNXT Team Classic | Insert | Matches And Moments | |
| 11 | Shane Thorne Defeats Roderick Strong | WWE NXT | Insert | Matches And Moments | |
| 12 | The Authors of Pain Defeat #DIY in a Dusty Rhodes | WWETagNXT | Insert | Matches And Moments | |
| 13 | Andrade Cien Almas Defeats Cedric Alexander | WWE NXT | Insert | Matches And Moments | |
| 14 | Bobby Roode Defeats Tye Dillinger | NXT TakeOver: Toronto | Insert | Matches And Moments | |
| 15 | The Authors of Pain Defeat TM61 to win the 2016 Dusty | Rhodes Tag | Insert | Matches And Moments | |
| 16 | #DIY Defeat The Revival for the NXT Tag Team NXT | Championship | Insert | Matches And Moments | |
| 17 | Samoa Joe Defeats Shinsuke Nakamura for the NXT | Championship | Insert | Matches And Moments | |
| 18 | SAnitY Gang Up on No Way Jose | WWE NXT | Insert | Matches And Moments | |
| 19 | Samoa Joe Defeats Tye Dillinger | WWE NXT | Insert | Matches And Moments | |
| 20 | Shinsuke Nakamura Defeats Samoa Joe for his Second | WWE NXT | Insert | Matches And Moments | |
| 21 | Shinsuke Nakamura Defeats Samoa Joe in a Steel Cage | WWEMatch | Insert | Matches And Moments | |
| 22 | Bobby Roode Wins the NXT Championship No. 1 | Contender's | Insert | Nxt | |
| 23 | #DIY Defeats TM61 | WWE NXT | Insert | Nxt | |
| 24 | #DIY Defeat The Revival to retain the NXT Tag Team | Championship | Insert | Nxt | |
| 25 | TM61 Defeat The Revival | WWE NXT | Insert | Wwe Nxt | |
| 26 | Eric Young Defeats Tye Dillinger | NXT TakeOver: San Antonio | Insert | Wwe Nxt | |
| 27 | The Authors of Pain Defeat #DIY for the NXT Tag NXT | Team | Insert | Wwe Nxt | |
| 28 | Seth Rollins Interrupts the show to call out Triple HNXT TakeOver: San Antonio | Insert | Wwe Nxt | ||
| 29 | Bobby Roode Defeats Shinsuke Nakamura for the NXT | Championship | Insert | Wwe Nxt | |
| 30 | SAnitY Defeat Tye Dillinger, No Way Jose & Roderick | Strong | Insert | Wwe Nxt | |
| 31 | Kassius Ohno Returns to NXT | WWE NXT | Insert | Wwe Nxt | |
| 32 | The Authors of Pain Defeat #DIY by DisqualificationWWE NXT | Insert | Wwe Nxt | ||
| 33 | Shinsuke Nakamura Defeats TJP | WWE NXT | Insert | Wwe Nxt | |
| 34 | Bobby Roode Defeats Kassius Ohno | WWE NXT | Insert | Wwe Nxt | |
| 35 | Kassius Ohno Defeats Elias in a Loser Leaves NXTWWE | MatchNXT | Insert | Wwe Nxt | |
| 36 | SAnitY Defeat Tye Dillinger, Kassius Ohno, Ruby NXT | Insert | Wwe Nxt | ||
| 37 | Aleister Black Debuts, Defeating Andrade Cien Almas | Insert | Wwe Nxt | ||
| 38 | NXT Tag Team Champions The Authors of Pain Defeat | Insert | Wwe Nxt | ||
| 39 | NXT Champion Bobby Roode Defeats Shinsuke Nakamura | Insert | Wwe Nxt | ||
| 40 | Oney Lorcan Defeats El Vagabundo | WWE NXT | Insert | Wwe Nxt | |
| 41 | Drew McIntyre Returns, Defeating Oney Lorcan | WWE NXT | Insert | Wwe Nxt | |
| 42 | Tye Dillinger Defeats Eric Young in a Steel Cage Match | Insert | Wwe Nxt | ||
| 43 | WWE United Kingdom Champion Tyler Bate DefeatsWWE | Gentleman | Insert | Wwe Nxt | |
| 44 | Hideo Itami Defeats Roderick Strong in an NXT WWEChampionship | Insert | Wwe Nxt | ||
| 45 | Hideo Itami Puts Bobby Roode to Sleep | WWE NXT | Insert | Wwe Nxt | |
| 46 | Roderick Strong Defeats Eric Young | NXT TakeOver: Chicago | Insert | Wwe Nxt | |
| 47 | Pete Dunne Defeats Tyler Bate for the WWE United | Kingdom | Insert | Wwe Nxt | |
| 48 | NXT Champion Bobby Roode Defeats Hideo Itami NXT TakeOver: Chicago | Insert | Wwe Nxt | ||
| 49 | NXT Tag Team Champions The Authors of Pain Defeat | NXT#DIY | Insert | Wwe Nxt | |
| 50 | Tommaso Ciampa Turns on Johnny Gargano | NXT TakeOver: Chicago | Insert | Wwe Nxt | |
| A-BY | Bayley | NXT Called Up | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-DA | Dean | Ambrose | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-TH | Triple H | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-AC | Adam Cole | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-AK | Akam | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-AB | Aleister Black | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-AW | Alexander Wolfe | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-AA | Andrade Cien Almas | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-AD | Angelo Dawkins | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-BF | Bobby Fish | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-BM | Buddy Murphy | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-CB | Cezar Bononi | 1ST NXT CARD | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-DM | Drew McIntyre | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-EY | Eric Young | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-FA | Fabian Aichner | 1ST NXT CARD | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-JG | Johnny | Gargano | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-ON | Kassius Ohno | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-KD | Killian Dain | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-UA | Kyle O'Reilly | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-LS | Lars Sullivan | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-LR | Lio Rush | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-MF | Montez Ford | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-NM | Nick Miller | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-NW | NO WAY Jose | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-OL | Oney Lorcan | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-OD | Otis Dozovic | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-PD | Pete Dunne | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-RE | Rezar | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-RM | Riddick Moss | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-RS | Roderick Strong | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-ST | Shane Thorne | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-TS | Tino Sabbatelli | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-TC | Tommaso Ciampa | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-TK | Tucker Knight | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-TB | Tyler Bate | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-VD | Velveteen Dream | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-WB | Wesley Blake | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-AY | Aliyah | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-BB | Bianca Belair | 1ST NXT CARD | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-BK | Billie Kay | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-EM | Ember Moon | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-KS | Kairi Sane | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-LE | Lacey Evans | 1ST NXT CARD | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-NC | Nikki Cross | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-PR | Peyton Royce | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-SH | Shayna Baszler | 1ST NXT CARD | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-TY | Taynara Conti | 1ST NXT CARD | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-VB | Vanessa Borne | 1ST NXT CARD | Autograph | Autographs | |
| A-ZV | Zelina Vega | NXT | Autograph | Autographs | |
| DA-ID | Peyton Royce | NXT | Autograph | Dual Autographs | |
| DA-ID | Billie Kay | NXT | Autograph | Dual Autographs | |
| DA-DY | Triple H | NXT | Autograph | Dual Autographs | |
| DA-DY | William Regal | NXT | Autograph | Dual Autographs | |
| TA-SAY | Eric Young | NXT | Autograph | Triple Autographs | |
| TA-SAY | Alexander Wolfe | NXT | Autograph | Triple Autographs | |
| TA-SAY | Killian Dain | NXT | Autograph | Triple Autographs | |
| TA-ERA | Adam Cole | NXT | Autograph | Triple Autographs | |
| TA-ERA | Bobby Fish | NXT | Autograph | Triple Autographs | |
| TA-ERA | Kyle O'Reilly | NXT | Autograph | Triple Autographs | |
| TA-MCA | Ember Moon | NXT | Autograph | Triple Autographs | |
| TA-MCA | Nikki Cross | NXT | Autograph | Triple Autographs | |
| TA-MCA | Aliyah | NXT | Autograph | Triple Autographs | |
| TA-MAG | Drew McIntyre | NXT | Autograph | Triple Autographs | |
| TA-MAG | Andrade | Cien Almas NXT | Autograph | Triple Autographs | |
| TA-MAG | Johnny Gargano | NXT | Autograph | Triple Autographs | |
| AR-EY | Eric | Young | Autograph Relic | Autograph Shirt Relic Cards | |
| AR-AW | Alexander | Wolfe | Autograph Relic | Autograph Shirt Relic Cards | |
| AR-NC | Nikki Cross | NXT | Autograph Relic | Autograph Shirt Relic Cards | |
| AR-AK | Akam | NXT Called Up | Autograph Relic | Autograph Shirt Relic Cards | |
| AR-RZ | Rezar | NXT Called Up | Autograph Relic | Autograph Shirt Relic Cards | |
| AR-EM | Ember | Moon | Autograph Relic | Autograph Shirt Relic Cards | |
| AR-AA | Andrade Cien | Almas | Autograph Relic | Autograph Shirt Relic Cards | |
| AR-NW | No Way | Jose | Autograph Relic | Autograph Shirt Relic Cards |